DONATE

Listen Now

 

   

Copper Creek

The Copper Creek Pack was the first pack created from reintroduced wolves in Colorado. There was deep joy for the first pups born from the relocation efforts, followed by tremendous stress when wolves started killing livestock. We hear from one of the first ranching families to lose livestock to a reintroduced wolf and the challenges they faced to qualify for compensation from Colorado Parks and Wildlife. In an already challenging and slim-margin profession, their experience highlighted the frustrations and emotional toll some ranchers feel living with the reality of wolves.  

Wolves are Political 

When the vote for wolf reintroduction passed by such a narrow margin, Senator Dylan Roberts knew it was going to be a difficult and controversial issue for the state, and his constituents along the Western Slope in particular. Trust between ranchers and CPW was broken when wolves hit the ground without all the supports in place. But while the initial reintroduction didn’t unfold as many would have liked, there is hope that the early stumbles lead to something sustainable, for wolves, for ranchers, and for the institutions that must somehow hold it all together. 

Lessons from Year One

There's no simple instruction manual for reintroducing an apex predator to a landscape. The first year taught CPW hard lessons -- about communication, about capacity, about the gap between what people expect and what’s actually possible. And since then, they've tried to adapt with more staff, outreach, and tools. But even with better resources, some challenges remain fundamental. You can't track every wolf. You can't predict every moment. You can't prevent every conflict. This is a real-time adaptive management process.

Image credit: Colorado Parks and Wildlife 

Our Moral Obligation 

With many wild animals at their lowest populations in history, some conservationists argue that preserving species is a moral obligation because they deserve to be on the planet as much as humans. Balancing different values in conservation decisions is never easy or perfect. It’s not as simple as weighing a rancher's livelihood against a wolf's place in the landscape. It’s about respect for these different value systems, finding ways to compromise, and a willingness to learn as we go. 

Doug Bruchez, Rancher, Reeder Creek Ranch
Dylan Roberts, Colorado State Senator, Senate District 8
Eric Odell, Wolf Conservation Program Manager, Colorado Parks and Wildlife
Carl Safina, Endowed Professor for Nature and Humanity, Stony Brook University; Founder, The Safina Center

Further Reading

"Dr. Joanna Lambert: Gray wolf reintroduction", SciLine, December 8, 2023.   

"Wolves and the West: The Cost of Coexistence", by Daniel Munch, American Farm Bureau Federation, July 7, 2025.

"The Real Case for Saving Species: We Don’t Need Them, But They Need Us", by Carl Safina, The Safina Center, October 2, 2023.    

Continue Exploring This Series

All Episodes